What’s the Best Home Automation System?

May 17, 2014 home automation, smart home, smartthings, 3 Comments
Best Home Automation


Knowing what the best home automation system available is after reading through all the previously posted articles may be a little difficult. I will mention what my favorite system is and why, and I’ll also mention a few systems that garner “honorable mention” honors.

What are the Choices?

There is a growing list of companies that are making some of the best home automation products on the market today. Some of these systems are from companies you’ve definitely heard of such as Lowe’s and Schlage. Some of them are from companies you may have never heard of unless you’re a professional low voltage and controls system installer, such as Crestron. There are also a plethora of individual devices and complete systems from many well-known and not-so-well-known, newly formed companies. My favorite just happens to be from one of those smaller and newer companies. This product is called SmartThings.

Why is SmartThings the Best Home Automation Product?

I can answer this question quite simply: It’s open source. The fact that it’s open source means that anyone can develop a product or sensor for it, plus the requisite programming code to make that product or sensor work the way they want it to. Dozens of people already have. Here are a couple examples:

  • User wackware created an app he calls “Potty Train the Dog.” This app consists of a moisture sensor and an alarm. When the sensor detects moisture in the area it’s placed in, it signals the system to sound the alarm, making the dog stop peeing.
  • User HelixWuff is developing a sensor system for use in hot tubs to constantly check qualities, such as Ph and temperature.
  • User bia.migueis built a device and app that tells the user when their houseplants need watering.

All the major players in the home automation market have products that will turn the lights in your house on and off from afar, usually over the Internet. They also have apps and products that will integrate with your home security system and turn it on or off and even unlock the doors to let service people in or let you know when the kids come and go. But they’re all limited to the products that are available from the company whose product you bought. The only limit that I’ve been able to see with SmartThings is the imagination of the user community.

SmartThings is ZigBee and Z-Wave Compatible

SmartThings app - Best Home AutomationZigBee and Z-Wave are two of the major home automation communication protocols in use today. Most of the products available for home automation are compatible with either or both of these protocols. Any device that is ZigBee or Z-Wave compatible will work with the SmartThings system. Although the SmartThings hub doesn’t directly use Wi-Fi (as we know it for computer networks), there is an extra port on the hub that can connect to a Wi-Fi router, enabling that wireless router to be used to communicate with Wi-Fi enabled devices throughout the house. They even plan to integrate near-field communication (NFC) in the next iteration of the product (Remember the Samsung Galaxy cell phone commercials where people trade data just by touching phones? That’s NFC.)

This means that SmartThings works with any device available on the market except the few that work with systems that use a proprietary communication protocol. This means there are literally hundreds of devices that can be used with a SmartThings system that you can buy separately, when you need it. In other words, you don’t have to buy a device that you’re never going to use if you decide to use the SmartThings home automation product.

Sure, it’s always nice to buy things from a nationally recognized name, such as Lowe’s, Schlage, Crestron, and AT&T. When you buy a product line from a large name company, you can be assured you are getting a trusted level of quality with that product. However, I personally don’t see this as an issue when I compare it to the fact that SmartThings lets me design and create my own sensors and control devices to do things that nobody else has thought of. To me, that sort of system flexibility is more important than a nationally known name behind the product and makes this the best home automation product on the market. As far as I’m concerned, there’s only one problem with SmartThings, and it is, admittedly, a pretty significant one. There’s a waiting list to acquire the basic system. I recommend you get on that list now.

Photo credit: Gramophone Maryland


CABLE & SATELLITE TV

STARTING AT: $2999/MO

STARTING AT: $1999/MO

HIGH SPEED INTERNET


Enter your address to see available offers


SEE OFFERS



The following two tabs change content below.
Mike is a certified low voltage installer with over 10 years of professional experience in the field, much of it working for Cable TV companies. He also has over a decade of experience in the computer field as a network engineer and support specialist. Mike's hobbies include installing high-end audio and video systems.

3 Comments

  • craig

    Can smartthings work in australia? A mate of mine is in the market. Is it compatable with the systems down under? THX!

  • Jack

    I know this article dates back to May but I was hoping you might offer some advice. I am a 58 year old tech savvy man that finds himself unemployed. I won’t bother with gory details and cut to the chase. I am the guy that family and friends turn to when they want to know what components to buy or how to solve issues with their PC or to set up their home theater etc. I am the guy who wife wants to divorce because he owns every conceivable gadget (most of which became obsolete shortly after purchase). The guy fiddling with Leap Motion, Z-Wave and uses his tablet to “control things” and listen to music, blah blah blah. Although ticking off your spouse by messing with her TV while sitting on the john can be fun.
    I want to (within reason) fast track myself into a Home Automation Design/Sales/Installation. There, I said it. I want to do what you have taken a decade to learn how to do AND I want to do it soon. I am pretty quick at picking things up and have owned my own business (albeit a failing UPS Store that sucked me dry over 7 years). Still, successful or not I learned how to manage the business side of things. I am still holding an active S-Corp here in Florida and will have no issues obtaining the appropriate liability insurance etc. WHAT I REALLY NEED is to be given some sage advice as to how I can get what I need to know in the fastest way. If you say, go and work for someone who is doing want you want to do I will cringe. As if it were that easy. Here in Jacksonville, both skilled and unskilled labor far exceeds demand. I have tried to hook up with high end audio houses (a dying concept even in more affluent neighborhoods), combed the classified in techie publications as well as the want ad classifieds. On that rare interview I find that what they are really looking for is an $8.00 per hour Attic Crawler or Supply Gopher. Brick and Mortar is pretty much a thing of the past unless you are a Big Box and most of them are gearing to the Do-it-yourself crowd (Lowes Iris). You are either a subcontracted installer or on your own. I live in a golf club community. There is a need for someone willing to retrofit these 30 year old homes with automation. There are ways of selling it. There are dozens just like this one within a 20 mile radius. That is my target. I can do my own ad copy, brochures etc. What I need is some direction as to where I can get the particle knowledge needed to do the job. I want to avoid the pitfalls by using the right technology, brands and products etc. What have you got for me??

  • Jack

    BTW, it sad when you type with two fingers and must keep your eyes glued to the key board. So please excuse the typos.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement